Skip to content
logo The magazine for beauty, fashion and well-being
Beauty Essential

The Best Eyebrow Pencils for Full and Perfectly Shaped Brows

Eyebrow Pencils
Eyebrows Complete the Makeup Look Photo: Getty Images

June 19, 2025, 1:19 pm | Read time: 5 minutes

Eyebrows are an essential part of any makeup routine. For those not naturally blessed with full brows, an eyebrow pencil can be used to fill them in and add the finishing touch.

Share article

Eyebrow styling has long been an essential part of daily makeup routines. The once-popular, thinly plucked lines have almost completely disappeared. Today, brows give the face expression, create accents, and can change the entire look. Whether naturally bushy or precisely defined, playing with shape is simply fun. No wonder the eyebrow pencil has become a must-have tool. STYLEBOOK has taken a closer look at the six most popular eyebrow pencils for you.

What Eyebrow Styling Is Trending Now?

Natural Look

Currently, expression and naturalness are clearly in focus. Instead of perfectly symmetrical brows, it’s about authentic, individual shapes. Fuller eyebrows with fine hair strokes appear soft, natural, and give the face a fresh look.

Soft-Filling Technique

The so-called soft-filling technique is very popular. It involves gently filling in the brow with fine, short strokes without completely coloring it in. The color is applied only in spots to fill in sparse areas and emphasize the natural arch.

Microblading Look

If you love the look of microblading (tattooed brows) but don’t want permanent makeup, you can achieve similar effects with the right eyebrow pencil. It’s important to have an ultra-fine tip that allows you to precisely and convincingly draw individual hairs.

Bold Emphasis

Brows can be more prominently emphasized and dominate the makeup look. Clearly defined contours, a filled-in shape, and a slightly lifted arch bring intensity and structure to the face, especially when combined with a clean look or bold lipstick.

More on the topic

What Makes a Good Eyebrow Pencil?

The Right Color

A common mistake is styling the brows too dark. Choose a shade just slightly darker than your natural brow color for light hair, and one to two shades lighter for dark hair. A cooler tone is important, as too warm colors can make the brows look artificial and reddish.

Durability

A good eyebrow pencil is sweat-resistant, water- and smudge-proof, even during sports and heat.

Consistency

The pencil should be neither too soft nor too hard. Soft pencils are ideal for filling in gently, while firm pencils allow for precise strokes. Powdery textures appear particularly natural and gel-based variants provide more structure and hold.

Fine Tip

Fine pencils are suitable for thin or sparse brows and precise hair strokes, while broader variants are ideal for full shapes and quick filling.

Ingredients

Look for vegan formulations and avoid parabens or microplastics. Nourishing ingredients such as vitamin E or plant oils are often included and support natural brow care.

Price-Performance Winner: NYX Professional Make-up Micro Brow Pencil

Thanks to its ultra-fine tip, it perfectly mimics individual hairs. The integrated brush effortlessly blends the color for a natural finish, while the vegan formula ensures long-lasting wear.

  • Price: approx. 7 euros
  • Number of Colors: 10
  • Features: Integrated brush, vegan formula

xxhttps://www.flaconi.de/make-up/nyx-professional-makeup/micro/nyx-professional-makeup-micro-brow-pencil-augenbrauenstift.html?variant=80072220-0.1-2

For Deceptively Real, Fine Hairs: Benefit Cosmetics Mighty Micro Brow Pencil

With three ultra-fine 0.1 mm tips, it perfectly mimics real hairs and instantly adds fullness and definition with a microblading effect. The intense, water- and sweat-resistant color lasts up to 24 hours without smudging or fading.

  • Price: approx. 21 euros
  • Number of Colors: 8
  • Features: 3 tips for microblading effect, long-lasting, waterproof

xxhttps://www.flaconi.de/make-up/benefit-cosmetics/mighty-fine/benefit-cosmetics-mighty-fine-brow-pen-augenbrauenstift.html?variant=90010732-0016815

For Especially Precise Strokes: Benefit Cosmetics Precisely, My Brow Pencil

The smudge-proof formula provides up to 12 hours of wear, and the extremely fine pencil allows for precise hair-like strokes, making even very fine brows appear fuller. Ideal for a natural yet perfectly defined look.

  • Price: approx. 20 euros
  • Number of Colors: 12
  • Features: Extremely fine tip, 12-hour wear

xxhttps://www.flaconi.de/make-up/benefit-cosmetics/precisely-my-brow-pencil/benefit-cosmetics-precisely-my-brow-pencil-augenbrauenstift.html?variant=80070991-0.08-10

For Extra Long Hold: MAC Pro Brow Definer

The ultra-fine 1-mm tip ensures precise, hair-like strokes. The buildable, smudge- and water-resistant formula provides up to 24 hours of reliable hold. Enriched with nourishing ingredients like carnauba wax and castor, argan, and coconut oils, the color glides effortlessly over the skin and conditions the brows. The integrated brush allows for a quick blend to a natural, soft finish.

  • Price: approx. 21 Euro
  • Number of Colors: 14
  • Features: Integrated brush, smudge- and water-resistant

xxhttps://www.flaconi.de/make-up/mac/pro-brow/mac-pro-brow-definer-augenbrauenstift.html?variant=90006293-0009534

For Silky Shine: Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz

This ultra-fine retractable pencil is ideal for precisely defining and filling in eyebrows, especially in sparse or over-plucked areas. Depending on the pressure applied, the color can be applied softly or intensely. Enriched with vitamin E and plant oils, the texture provides an especially silky finish.

  • Price: approx. 19 euros
  • Number of Colors: 8
  • Special Features: Integrated brush, vegan formula with nourishing oils

xxhttps://www.flaconi.de/make-up/anastasia-beverly-hills/brow-wiz/anastasia-beverly-hills-brow-wiz-augenbrauenstift.html?variant=80057562-0.085-4

Für natürliche Brauen: L’Oréal Paris Brow Artist Xpert

Der L’Oréal Paris Brow Artist Xpert ist ein einfach zu bedienender Augenbrauenstift mit einer dreieckigen Spitze, die sowohl feine als auch breite Striche ermöglicht. Die wischfeste Formel sorgt für langanhaltende Ergebnisse, während das integrierte Bürstchen die Farbe gleichmäßig verteilt und die Brauen in Form bringt.

  • Preis: ca. 8 Euro
  • Anzahl Farben: 8
  • Besonderheiten: Dreieckige Spitze, integrierte Bürste

xxhttps://www.flaconi.de/make-up/l-oreal-paris/brow-artist/l-oreal-paris-brow-artist-xpert-augenbrauenstift.html?variant=80073160-0.2-3

This article is a machine translation of the original German version of STYLEBOOK and has been reviewed for accuracy and quality by a native speaker. For feedback, please contact us at info@stylebook.de.

Topics #falconi Best of Beauty
You have successfully withdrawn your consent to the processing of personal data through tracking and advertising when using this website. You can now consent to data processing again or object to legitimate interests.